The Stoneleaf

Observations from a yet another vantage point. About anything, that Matters!

Name:
Location: India

I am what I am, thats what I am!
Dreamer, Maverick, Socially Unacceptable!!

I...
I am the Ego, the ego supreme
I am Somnus, source of your dreams
I am the Sound, when silence screams
I am Everything, all that has been

Wednesday, December 24, 2008

Akarmanyata (Inaction) Continued

Dear Reader,

I am guilty of putting away efforts to hide under 'something else' to occupy my time, I am guilty of not having expressed what I think - WE should be thinking. I am guilty of procrastination which makes me no different from the other indifferent us. Those who crib about the system, and corruption and inaction and what difference does it make and the works, but refuse to do anything about it. We choose to remain silent, unmoved, dis-en-gaged, as a mark of protest against the state of the affairs, not realising that by staying mum all we are doing is add to inertia, the very thing that we want to change.

I have for days heard and read what actors, leaders, ministers, activists, celebrities, models, singers, strategists, and so called think-tanks have said or written. I would accept for almost all this time I had a cynical grin on my face thinking about how soon will this voice, and noise die down and Page 3 will prevail and how it all will just end up being a business case study. I had decided that my silence will be my protest against it, however I failed to realise that my silence will only help bring the pompoms sooner than they should. This was brought to my notice by an argument I had with someone who never fails to question my cynicism, and I realised that maybe that one more voice is really not so miniscule as all. Who knows when we reach the tipping point?

But procrastination never let me say what I wanted to say, everytime I read one of those articles/statements/slogans. I am not taking names here, but you know there is only so much that hollow sloganeering can do. And news channels HAVE to take care of their TRP's for their celebrity reporters, who become more celeb than attend to their primary responsibilty. However I should also accept that I never did my part. Today I realised, I dont have to. I read this one appeal by this young woman in Bangalore, and I know that I dont have to articulate the voids, that she has said what I have been wanting to. And here I go back to the shadows and give you this one by Payoshi Roy of Bishop Cotton School, Bangalore. Cheers to her, and that fact that not all of us are in the snarls of inaction. That there is some action after thought. And that is hope enough.

---

'STOP THINK CRY LOVE..'

The siege on Mumbai left even the most experienced of us stunned. Even those who have become immune to grief and tragedy stopped for asecond. The 48-hour encounter with these extremely sophisticated and trained terrorists of Pakistani origin left India burning in every sense of the word. The versions and accounts are endless. Trying to quantify people's grief would not only be futile but indeed low down. People who went for their daily evening session of beer and gossip atthe Leopold café, that special once a month dinner at the Taj or forthe bitter sweet occasion of farewell at CST Station never returned.


This isn't the first time we're hearing about something like this. These stories have been talked about through out this year and to be honest through out our lives. We have experienced five separate series of bomb blasts across the country in this year alone. The dreadful cries of the Gujarat riots are yet to recede from recent memories. The2006 and 1993 Bombay blasts and riots haunt their victims even now.

However, we are not here to talk about the grief that these victims suffer. Nor do I wish to discuss the various and repeated intelligence failures and lackadaisical attempts of the government and its security agencies. We are here to figure out what exactly is wrong with us,because it is evident that there is something horribly amiss in this country and it's people.

People are not born terrorists. Teenagers do not get up one fine daywith the conviction that violence is the path of their lives. The terrorist that battled with NSG in the Taj hotel for over 24 hours was not more that 25 years old. Can any of you imagine the kind of courage and determination that this young boy exemplified in accomplishing such a feat. He is a terrorist, a terrorist who is responsible for the death of over 150 people. He is also a mere boy. A boy whom we have forced into becoming the man he died as. The Indian mujahidin consists of young boys from the JMI College in Delhi. Sadhvi Pragya is in her early twenties. These people are our age. They are people who we seein movie halls and at street corners. They are not aliens of another race. Terrorism was not brought in from Mars. It breeds within us. The worst part is, that we created it.

Every kind of terrorism stems from extremism; and extremism is the most obvious ramification of discrimination. Discrimination is sadly practiced in every nook and corner of our country. We think it's insignificant, we think that it's just the way people are. But it is discrimination and if only we were brave enough to face it.

It is discrimination when the age-old story of Hindu parents refusing to marry their daughter into a Muslim family repeats itself. It is discrimination when parents of Muslim children refuse to sing Hindu bhajans. It is discrimination when Christians refuse to participate inHindu and Muslim festivals. All of this is discrimination. And every form of terrorism and extremism finds it's roots in this kind of discrimination, which is practiced in each and every one of our homes. That is why we need to look at our homes and our thinking before wecry out in rage and protest against the government and security forces.

Last night you had emotional and angry Mumbai mobs screaming out anti Pakistani slogans. That is the beginning of terrorism. Have we all gone mad? What does the normal Pakistani family who is probably intheir own way praying for the Mumbai victims have anything to do with this? This is the quintessential problem that we are facing. When will we realize that by blaming each other the problem will only intensify.

The Hindus destroyed the Babri masjid. The Muslims blew up a Hindu coach. The Hindus killed a city full of Muslims. Wave after wave of madness. Stop! How long can we go on like this? An eye for an eye has never been the answer and it should not take us a thousand years to accept the truth of this statement.

You had Raj Thakare chasing out the north Indians and Biharis from Maharashtra. Over three hundred North Indians of the NSG saved his beloved Marathi manoos. Where was Bal Thakare then? Forget about this one man, where were the rest of our cosmopolitan Mumbaikers who let this man get away with what he did.. Where were the progressive and peaceful Hindu leaders when churches burnt in Orissa and Karnataka? We should all hang our heads in shame.

In another 60 years we'll have Bihari terrorists attacking Maharashtra and Maharashtrian terrorist retaliating. Next we'll have border security squadrons for our state borders. Don't smile skeptically. TheIndia-Pakistan feud had also started off in 1947 with Muslims being chased out of Delhi and Hindus being chased out of Lahore. Look where it stands now.

Today you have every news channel proudly acclaiming the army, NSG andMarine commandos as heroes. People in Mumbai are running out on thestreets to congratulate them. These heroes weren't born today. They have been here all this while. Where were these people of India, theMedia, when the IAS used their Machiavellian minds to reduce the salaries of all the Defence Forces. Where were these people when the corporate world squabbled over a few hundred rupees rise in the salaries of these men who always risk their lives to keep us safe? I could not see the bureaucracy putting their life on the line to save hostages in the Trident. I did not see the corporate world dying at the border during the Kargil war. And I did not see Indian citizens who today call these soldiers heroes defending them when they needed us the most.

You want to know what the problem with India is? We're cowards. We don't think as a single nation and we can't stand up for what's right.

I'll give you a small and perfect example of what is wrong with us. We all complain about this country's dirty roads. We love holidaying in London's spick and span streets. The most educated of us are yet to hesitate while throwing a sweet wrapper or Lays packet on the street. Or we'll throw it in an already existing dump on the street. We can't even wait till we come across a dustbin. This is what is wrong with us.

We have enough and more to say about Manmohan Singh and Advani and every other useless politician and rightly so. But the fact is that in all honesty we couldn't care less. The best of us don't vote, don't contest in elections and don't even help out N.G.O.s When we can't do anything for our country how dare we, I repeat, how dare we expect anyone else to do anything.

We can go on talking about stepping up security, straightening out our coast guards and eradicating terrorism. But the problem lies not in our security system but in us. It lies in our madrassas, in our temples, in our schools in our homes and in our minds. And until we realize our role, until we open our eyes to this truth, not a thing will change.

Everyone talks about this new India, a shining progressive and youngIndia. Well it's time for Young, New and Shining India to prove herself. Stand up and prove your worth. This so- called liberal and progressive thinking generation needs to root out those weeds that grow in the oldest corners our gardens. We need to start thinking and start talking. Talking to ourselves and to others. We need to start doing. This has to be a national youth movement. We have to make it the beginning of a revolution. Every historic movement starts like this. Vague, uncertain and hesitant but moving towards a common calling motivated by the same inspiration and dream. This is our chance.

Don't tell me that we won't be able to reach out to the people who need to hear what we have to say. These people live among us. There is no limit to what people can achieve when they set out to do something.You are talking about a country whose founding father won a war without raising a weapon. Who have lived on stories of Subhash Chandra Bose calling out for blood and promising freedom. Well we've bled. Now it's time to get our freedom. Freedom from our own mindsets. Freedom from shackles we've placed on ourselves.

These last two days have been the worst attack that India has ever dealt with. If this alarm wasn't loud enough, no alarm will ever wakeus up.How many more people have to die before we respond to India's desperate plea for help?

----

Thank you Payoshi. I needed this wake-up call.

5 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

India has always shown good faith and extended a hand of friendship towards Pakistan. You do not see Indians going over to Pakistan bombing their cities or mosques.
And even when there have been a series of attacks on India, one more brutal than the other, we have maintained peace with all the people around us.
I agree there have been random riots in this wake, but you can hardly expect the grief stricken people to sit quietly just to show oneness. I have not seen anybody from any country do that.
Dear Payoshi you will always sit in your cozy home and make judgment calls on others, Or write a blog about how Indians are absolute hate mongers.
I have been many places and seen many cultures, believe me Indians may be brash and rude and a bit uncouth but they are ultimately very tolerable people.
We pick up our lives and move straight on, if we were so belligerent than we should have kicked out the Pakis from Kashmir and taken back what rightfully belongs to us.
If anything we should be a more aggressive country. Even today the Chinese trickle down slowly in to Arunachal Pradesh, in due time we will lose it to the Chinese and our fat useless politicians won’t do a thing about it.
If a Hindu marrying a Muslim or a Muslim marrying a Hindu, could settle our differences with Pakistan, why then the whole world can go that route right?
Please understand one thing, Pakistan wants to convert all of us infidels (as they call) and mainly they want to take our country, our motherland.Giving Kashmir is not going to satisfy them and neither is inter religious marriages.
Think of it this way- supposing someone attacked your mother, would you sit around and spread messages of peace, or go look around and tear open the world for her? Alas, Indians are not yet that passionate about tearing open the world to protect their country, but they will react the way every human wil react.

I very much agree with your views on issues plaguing Maharastra and other states.
My few cents worth of comments, may be it will change your perception of Indians, may be not, but do keep up your writing.

December 25, 2008 12:15 AM  
Blogger Ravali said...

@ Vivek - as your friend I believe it my right to be frank with you regarding your comment - I don't think it is nice of you to curse at Anonymous' comment. he is merely stating his opinion and we should respect because one of the main things Payoshi tries to convey in her post is the need for tolerance of other's views. if we cannot even tolerate Anonymous' comment and his way of expressing passion for our country how can we ever have the inner strength and insight to not merely tolerate but connect and befriend the terrorists who are but boys and girls our age with a passion as well for a cause of their own. we have to be careful that our drive and passion is going towards love and not hate. don't hate Anonymous, he/she is one is us as well. we have to unite but that doesn't mean we have to think alike. we may all have our reasons, our perspectives and our ways of approaching and defining life, that shouldn't stop us from loving one another. dont' be mad at what Anonymous says, behind his/her words is great passion and love for India as well.

@ Anonymous - I am also sitting in a cozy chair, a warm house far away from India and even farther away from any grief, tragedy or calamity in my house. I am not experienced in handling distress and am really too young to have ever been really burdened by most of life's hurdles and harshness. as a very sheltered child of loving family I may be more of an idealist by nature than a realist. my relatively serene circumstances has shaped me thus just as those 21 and 25 year old boys are drenched in hate and vengeance because of the brutal and debilitating circumstances that have shaped their views. we cannot do much about our circumstance but we can work a great deal on ourselves with volition and will-power.
1. it takes great amount of self-discipline to overcome family tragedies. if my mother or father were killed, i would be very enraged as well but all my beautiful life with my parents before that would hopefully have enough love to stop me from hurting someone else. what is our love and patriotism for our country worth if we cannot spread respect other countries. when you blame "pakis" it really hurts me, because even if the terrorists are pakistani, the country is not a cult of terrorists. there are just as many indian terrorists in the world as pakistani terrorists. that does not make every indian evil or inhuman. we are all one, we are all individual. think, today if an alien spaceship threatens our planet, then what indians what pakistanis. wouldn't we all care to come together to save human race ? then there would be no countries there would be one planet. just as at the time of mumbai tragedy, people from every state of India prayed and worked to saved the victims.

January 07, 2009 8:16 AM  
Anonymous kiran said...

Bravo Payoshi. It is true that there is so much we can do and we should do. all in day to day life. but most people do think hatred is the only way of manifesting patriotism. and it somehow comes out only during some tragic events or may be cricket matches. is that all love for country means?
I think it is mainly because,we are used to blaming others for everything that happens, instead of looking within us. we never look at ourselves and see if we are doing our part correctly. all daily simple things, that might vary from keeping roads clean and voting during election as payoshi pointed to helping others and creating trust over each other.
Anonymous gave example of mother being killed. but if you are an irresponsible son who has refused to care for her in whole life, and starved her and tortured her, what right do you have to retaliate her death? if you do, it will be just because of your ego and not because of your love, as you have really never loved her or cared for her.

September 18, 2009 12:54 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Heya thiѕ is kindа of off topic but I was
ωantіng to know if blogs uѕe WYЅIWYG eԁitoгs or іf уou havе to
manually code wіth НΤML. І'm starting a blog soon but have no coding experience so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be enormously appreciated!

My weblog: augen lasern

April 13, 2013 2:53 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

What's up mates, good post and good arguments commented here, I am really enjoying by these.

Feel free to surf to my web blog augenoperation

April 16, 2013 11:11 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home